LOUISE PENNY’S

The Bistro

The Bistro

The Bistro Banner
Join us here in The Bistro for a discussion on the entire Gamache series. Feel free to ask or answer any questions about any of the books or the series as a whole.

Discussion on “The Bistro”

I watched THREE PINES on Amazon Prime Friday night. I loved it and hope there will be a second season. I wish they would have shown the personalities of the characters a little more in depth; but all in all, it was excellent. As someone who has read all of Louise Penny’s books, I have found myself getting to know all the characters and looking forward in each new book to visiting Three Pines and catching up with each of them. I love Ruth and her duck; she is priceless. Inspector Gamache is what all detectives should be like, caring. Looking forward to 2023’s book.

Just watched THREE PINES. Think it was superb.Molina seems to grow into Gamache’s skin. Actually, all of the cast seems to be bespoke. Poor Nathaniel Parker does not deserve all of the criticism. If you pretend that you know nothing about the series, and view it as a stand-alone
flick, it is enjoyable. How many episodes will there be and how often will they air? Worse than waiting for the next book!

Overall, a disappointment. Gamache and Jean Guy the best casting. After that, the acting was just not up to par. Alfred Molina very, very good.
I have waited patiently for this series. I will finish it, of course, but even the Bistrot was a disappointment. General agreement from all my “bookie” friends.
Having said all that, I cannot imagine what it would have taken to get this to the small screen.
6 more episodes to go. We’ll see.

I loved the Gamache books from the beginning and have read all but the newest at least twice. And I loved the first two episodes of Three Pines. So interesting to see how the characters are represented. Molina is great as Gamache! Looking forward to the remaining episodes and YES to another season!!!

I enjoyed Louise in person in Ann Arbor, MI last night, then went home and watched the first two episodes on Prime. It’s going to take awhile to acclimate to these actors as the characters. Molina is very good!

I used to read when things got quiet on the night shift via audiobook, (bad wyes). I really enjoyed it but then I retired & couldn’t find the time or enough interest, with so much else (living) to do. I didn’t think I missed it, but someone turned me on to the Gamache 3 Pines mysteries. I fell, hook, line & sinker!

Between November & Februaryi read them all, in order. Then,😱, I ran out, and have been waiting for the next one. I am afraid. I feel like an addict who was for ed to go cold turkey. I know I will love it when I read it, but even if I read it twice, the day will come when I will turn the last page, and then ….
It’s too long a wait.
What if Ms Penny takes a sabbatical, or decides to give up writing altogether???
Arrggghhhhh!

I’m in the midst of A World of Curiosities and am so happy to see Amelia ! I’ve been wondering about her- I get so involved in these books- it’s hard for me to separate real life from Three Pines!

Big thumbs down, not even close to the empathy of Gamache much less the wisdom that comes with age & experience ( besides selleck pushes guns ).

I was a bit disappointed with Armand Gamanche, although I loved Alfred Molina, but expected him to have a French accent, which to me, is always appealing. Beauvoir looks too old for a son in law, and Nicole not the Nicole I imagined. She was meant to be young, and surly looking, brooding.
However, was so excited to be in Three Pines, as I have missed it and all the characters since finishing the last book a couple of months ago. I need really, and it is my current dream, to hop back on a plane and fly over to Quebec and wander the streets of Knowlton and indeed a lot of Quebec. (I have been to Quebec, but not for nearly long enough!) But hopefully, we will be able to next year. It’s a long, long way from Australia.xxx

Oh no…Tom is the stoic Jesse Stone, Chief of Police in Paradise or Frank Regan head of the NYPD and of an incredibly service oriented family or that very young Magnum PI catching bad guys in Hawaii… never Gamache;-)

Yes I can see it but imagine he might be too old. Oh my! That’s a reversal. Usually women actors are carefully chosen for their age and looks.

Oh, ya…he’d have been good. But I’m still thinking that an unknown Quebec individual would have been even more perfect. I feel like it’s a missed opportunity.

While waiting for A World of Curiosities, I reread the entire series. My love for Louise Penny, Three Pines, Gamache and all of the other wonderful characters was only further cemented by reading one book after another in quick succession. A World of Curiosities may be my favorite so far, because of the complex weaving of storylines, backstories, and characters. Louise is such a genuine, caring person, and it shows in her work, not only the novels, but her newsletters, social media, and in interviews. When I first discovered Still Life, it was just before the fourth book in the series was due out. Reading it caused me to do something I’d never done before: Contact an author. Louise’s writing style had such an impact on me, a life-long reader of mysteries and thrillers, because it was so different in the best possible way. And to my surprise and delight, Louise herself wrote back to me! For that kindness, and for the excellent stories she tells us all, I will forever be one of her greatest fans.

I have been unbelievably blessed by Three Pines and Louise Penny. I found her only a few years ago and have read each of her books. I’m again asking for her latest book, Curiosities, from my stepson for Christmas. Her recent interview including comments on the joy and peace that a 12 step program gives, brought knowing tears to my eyes . Thank you Louise Penny! Please come to Sedona, AZ.

I reread all the books in preparation for this new one, and it did not disappoint. My only regret is that I read it too fast and now I’m again longing for more. I love Ruth Zardo’s poetry! I’d love a book of it so I could savor it.

they are already published by the authors who wrote them that Louise Penny uses with permission: Margaret Atwood and Marylyn Plessner.

Ruth Poetry is amazing. I cried today reading

Oh yes, and breasts, and a sweet pear hidden in my body. Whenever there’s talk of demons, these come in handy. Death sits on my shoulder like a crow … Or a judge, muttering about sluts and punishment. And licking his lips.

Louise’s stories are so relevant to the issues and culture of our times and this piece of poetry so beautifully and painfully illustrates this.

I’ve just begun A World of Curiosities and am totally enthralled. I’m reading as slowly as I can so as not to miss anything. I adore all of Louise’s books.

I would also like to see Ruth’s poetry put together in a book. Her poetry is one of the gem’s I look forward to when reading the seroes/

I read A World of Curiosities in one day putting my life on hold and diving in to life in Three Pines. I meant to drag out reading your stunning, deeply thoughtful book slowly to make it last. I was completely out of control! Having read
every engrossing book in your series, I look forward to where you travel next with your fascinating Three Pines residents?
Thank you, for your talent, your dedication to your characters and your wonderful newsletters that take me along with you.

Hi, Jane! I did the same with All the Devils Are Here, devouring it in one Saturday. Then, I opened it up and read it again, savoring instead of devouring.

Louise’s December 2022 newsletter is as brilliantly crafted as her novels! Thank You for the smiles and warmth Louise!

I had the great pleasure of spending time with Louise and Deborah Crombie on Tuesday evening at the Dallas Arts & Letters event. I say spend time although I was just sitting in the audience, but felt like I was having a glass of wine and a conversation with old friends. What an absolute treat is was to listen to both these wonderful authors chat about the writing process, the charecters and their quirks, life, and travel. I will not forget that evening.

Being a part of Louise’s Gamache community which offers joy and satisfaction to everyone everywhere is a wonderful thing, a lucky thing.

I am enjoying “The World of Curiosities” very much and admire the way it delves into relevant, and often disturbing, issues. This real world quality and the way characters interact with those issues is what makes this series so special to me.

Louise wrote about this in her December 2022 newsletter. I’m thoroughly enjoying Joy, the Ernesto Cervini’s jazz album, based on Louise’s characters and books. As I listen to it, I try to determine which character the musical selections are based on, and Ernesto nails it. It’s wonderful to feel this extra connection to Three Pines through this beautiful music. I highly recommend Joy.

I played snippets of Cervini’s jazz album to my one year old granddaughter during lunch today. She had a fit when I stopped it as she was entranced! It was her first introduction to jazz, and won’t be her last!

I thought, being Stephen, he had an emergency fund set aside for contingencies, and to pay off the Prefect’s mortgage in France. What about the trust funds for the grandchildren? Surely he would have kept them safe. It is a mystery.

Love your books. I savour them.

If I had to cast Gamache it would have to be Hugh Bonneville. When I read your books it is he who I visualise.

I gave my unsolicited suggestions for the roles in Louise’s upcoming Amazon Prime series, “Three Pines”:
Hi, Louise!
I was just thinking how I cannot wait for the Amazon Series of Gamache to begin and how FABOO the casting of Alfred Molina is in the role of your/our beloved Armand.
Here are some of my suggestions for other roles:

Ruth Zardo — Maggie Smith (if you get her, you’ll get everyone else)
JeanGuy — Colin Farrell
Frankur — Ciaran Hinds
Michelle Braybuf — Brendan Gleason
Olivier — Stuart Townsend
Gabri — Brendan Fraser
Clara — Marcia Gay Harden
Myrna — Octavia Spencer

It would be nice to see more Quebecois characters be Quebecers or at least French. You have chosen all British actors – all anglophones. The setting and feel of all the books is Quebecois – a vibrant passionate and bilingual community. I hope that is not lost in the new series. I am really looking forward to it.

Did anyone else notice this at the bottom of the most recent email from Louse:
“Do you have any questions or comments about Louise Penny’s books, GamacheSeries.com, or just want to chat with other readers? Please join us in the virtual Bistro! And we’ll see you next week to share our final feature. ”
FINAL FEATURE
Are they saying that a “World of Curiosities” will be Louise’s final Gamache book?

A World of Curiosities is superb. I couldn’t put it down and now I’m sad that I finished it! I loved the history, suspense, familiar and new characters and as always, it left me yearning for the next one. Thank you Louise!!!

We all have such rich and wonderful images in our minds of the community of Three Pines. I love to imagine their voices and mannerisms. What a gift Louise Penny has given us, right? Yesterday, I listened to Terry Gross on NPR interview Misty Copeland, ABT’s first Black Principal dancer. Many suggested that she could not play the Swan Queen in “Swan Lake” (and many other roles) because she is a women of color. She reminded us all that acting and interpreting a character is an art. I view Molina in the same way. He will be interpreting Gamache and will bring the character to life with passion, no doubt. Of course it will not fit neatly into our imagined visions we hold. But he will be excellent in my opinion.

I agree. I’m sure most readers form an idea in their mind of what a character looks or sounds like, so there’s no pleasing everyone. But Alfred Molina seems a good choice.

Leave a Reply to Stephen Russell McDonald Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

Skip to content